Full Ace tennis forums

Is it actually possible to win when you challenge a call?

Jay wrote:Is it actually possible to win when you challenge a call?

Yes, it is. Does it really happen often in real life ?

I would say around 10-15% of the time but I'm am just speculating based on matches I have watched.

Jay wrote:I would say around 10-15% of the time but I'm am just speculating based on matches I have watched.

Bottom line is, I tuned the margin of error of referees based on my own feeling, maybe it's a little low, and therefore they don't make enough mistakes. We'll need to see in the long run if it needs to be raised. But I definitely saw some with the current setting.

kschoice wrote:

Jay wrote:I would say around 10-15% of the time but I'm am just speculating based on matches I have watched.

Bottom line is, I tuned the margin of error of referees based on my own feeling, maybe it's a little low, and therefore they don't make enough mistakes. We'll need to see in the long run if it needs to be raised. But I definitely saw some with the current setting.

I'm not saying it's too low or too high as I have not played or challenged the system enough times to offer an opinion based on experience. I just wanted to know whether intentional incorrect line calling is employed .

kschoice wrote:

Jay wrote:I would say around 10-15% of the time but I'm am just speculating based on matches I have watched.

Bottom line is, I tuned the margin of error of referees based on my own feeling, maybe it's a little low, and therefore they don't make enough mistakes. We'll need to see in the long run if it needs to be raised. But I definitely saw some with the current setting.

To my opinion, I think you shall raise the margin of errors.

I have to say kschoice, I absolutely love the Fat-Challenge system or should I say FAT-EYE Keep it up.